From Liker to Lurker: How Instagram Has Changed & Easy Steps to Keep Up

If you’ve noticed your engagement numbers are lower lately, you’re not alone—and you haven't lost your touch. The way people consume content has undergone a fundamental shift. Since the meteoric rise of TikTok, user habits have changed across all platforms; we’ve moved away from the social era of scrolling through friends' photos and into a viewing culture.

Instagram is currently seeing a dip in traditional feed engagement, but the platform is far from dying. It still sees over 2 billion monthly active users, with the average user spending roughly 33 minutes per day on the app (Source: Statista/Business of Apps). The audience is still there; they’ve just transitioned from Likers to Lurkers. They are consuming more than ever, but interacting less with the "heart" button.

The Shift to "Interest Media"

We have officially entered the era of Interest Media. This is a term championed by Gary Vaynerchuk—a leading serial entrepreneur and digital visionary known for pinpointing consumer attention shifts long before they become mainstream.

As Vaynerchuk explains:

This is the current state of the internet and very important because interest media allows platforms to keep users on the platform longer because you’re seeing things you’re actually into now, not people you used to follow. The algorithm no longer prioritizes who you followed five years ago; it prioritizes what you are interested in right now. For a small business, this is a massive opportunity. It means your content can reach your ideal client based on their behaviour, even if they’ve never heard of your brand.

5 Strategic Steps to Refresh Your Presence

To stay relevant in an interest-based feed, you need to adjust your posting habits to match how the app actually functions:

• Increase Posting Frequency (sorry, it’s true): Every post is an entry into the lottery. Frequent posting gives the algorithm more opportunities to place you in Suggested Posts and on the Explore Page.
  

• Add Trial Reels: Trial Reels are designed to be a discovery tool. Because they are served to people who do not follow you, they act as the widest part of your funnel to attract new eyes.
  

• Refine Your Call to Action (CTA): Instead of asking for a "like," prioritize the Share. Encourage users to "share this with a friend" or "post this to your stories." Shares are the highest form of currency in the current algorithm.
  

• Design for the DM: Deepen your brand's personality through "shareable" lifestyle content. Much of the platform's social interaction has moved from public comments to private Direct Messages.
  

• Show Up in Stories: While Trial Reels find new people, Stories nurture your existing community. Ensure your settings allow followers to share your Stories to their own, turning your audience into your best advocates.
  

Staying Top-of-Mind (The Sales Funnel in Action)

Don’t be discouraged if your follower count feels stagnant or your "likes" are lower than they used to be—it’s not a reflection of your work. Instagram now provides views as a primary metric because reach is the new benchmark for success.

In a crowded digital landscape, the most important goal is to remain top-of-mind. This is the Sales Funnel in action: it’s the journey someone takes from discovering your brand to finally making a purchase. People generally need to see you consistently before they develop the trust to buy from you. By pivoting your strategy to focus on interest and sharing, you ensure your business stays at the forefront of your customers' minds—even if they’re just "lurking" for now.

---

MORE FROM SWEET TALK

Ready to stop guessing? We're booking Marketing Strategy Consultations to align your content calendar with your sales goals and storytelling. We’ll build a custom system for your messaging and ads—built with intention and a deep understanding of how to post—while connecting you with local photographers for custom visuals. Click here to book your consultation and get your business in front of the right audience for 2027.